poker legal in india

As of my last update in April 2023, the legal status of poker in India is complex and has undergone changes over time. This article aims to provide an updated overview of the current situation. Brief History of Poker’s Legality in India Poker was initially considered a game of chance and therefore not permissible under Indian law, which prohibits gambling activities that are seen as games of chance. However, with the advancement of technology and the rise of online gaming platforms, poker has gained popularity in the country.

  • Lucky Ace Palace
    new
    Luck&Luxury100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Cash King Palace
    Royal Wins100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Starlight Betting Lounge
    Celestial Bet100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Silver Fox Slots
    Elegance+Fun100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Spin Palace Casino
    Win Big Now100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Golden Spin Casino
    Luxury Play100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Lucky Ace Casino
    Luck&Luxury100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Royal Fortune Gaming
    Opulence & Thrills100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Diamond Crown Casino
    Opulence & Fun100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more
  • Victory Slots Resort
    Spin to Win100% / $1500
    Casino popularity:
    Collecting more data...
    Payment methods
    • Mifinity
    • Google Pay
    • PIX
    • EcoPayz
    • Neteller
    • Apple Pay
    • Visa
    • Sofort
    • Interac
    • Wagering: 35 x (b)
    • Withdrawal time: 1 days
    • Minimum deposit to casino: $30
    • Bonus max bet: $5
    • Established: 2024
    • Free Spins: 200
    • 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
    • Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
    • Leading selection of slots
    • VISA casino site
    • HD streaming casino games
    • Newly unveiled casino
    • Signup offer now available
    • Mr. Gamble special bonuses
    Show more

As of my last update in April 2023, the legal status of poker in India is complex and has undergone changes over time. This article aims to provide an updated overview of the current situation.

Brief History of Poker’s Legality in India

Poker was initially considered a game of chance and therefore not permissible under Indian law, which prohibits gambling activities that are seen as games of chance. However, with the advancement of technology and the rise of online gaming platforms, poker has gained popularity in the country.

A significant shift in the legal perspective regarding poker occurred with the Supreme Court of India’s decision in 2017 (State of Andhra Pradesh vs K. Veerabhadra Yuvaraju). The court ruled that card games like poker should be considered a skill game rather than a game of chance, potentially making them legal.

Skill or Chance?

The classification of poker as either a skill game or a game of chance has been the subject of much debate and litigation in India. If poker is deemed a game of skill, then it might not fall under gambling laws that prohibit games of chance. This distinction could be crucial for determining the legality of online poker sites and land-based operations.

As of my last update, while there have been court decisions and state-level regulations suggesting a more favorable stance towards poker as a game of skill, the legal status remains somewhat ambiguous at the national level. The Union Territory of Goa has issued licenses for poker operators, but this does not necessarily mean that all forms of poker are legal across India.

Online Poker Platforms

Many online poker platforms have gained popularity in India despite the uncertain regulatory environment. These platforms often operate internationally and might be subject to international gaming regulations rather than Indian law. However, users should exercise caution and ensure they understand any potential risks involved with playing on such sites from within India.

The legality of poker in India is complex and has evolved over time. The classification as a skill game or a game of chance continues to influence the legal status. While there have been positive indicators, including court decisions and specific state-level regulations, clarity at the national level remains elusive. Users interested in playing poker should be aware of these complexities.

Note on Regulation

For any individual contemplating engaging with online gaming platforms, it is essential to stay updated on local laws and regulations. The legal status can change, and personal financial risks are always involved when participating in gambling activities.


The content of this article aims at providing an informative overview of the current state regarding poker’s legality in India as of my last update. Please note that the situation may have evolved since then. For those looking for more detailed or updated information, it is advisable to consult legal experts or official government sources.

texasholdem

Texas Hold’em is arguably the most popular variant of poker, captivating players worldwide with its strategic depth and thrilling gameplay. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or a complete novice, understanding the nuances of Texas Hold’em can elevate your poker experience. This article delves into the rules, strategies, and cultural impact of this iconic card game.

The Basics of Texas Hold’em

Game Setup

  • Players: Typically, Texas Hold’em is played with 2 to 10 players.
  • Deck: A standard 52-card deck is used.
  • Blinds: Two players are required to place forced bets, known as blinds, to initiate the betting.

Game Structure

  1. Preflop: Each player is dealt two hole cards face down. The first round of betting begins.
  2. Flop: Three community cards are dealt face up in the middle of the table. Another round of betting ensues.
  3. Turn: A fourth community card is dealt, followed by a third round of betting.
  4. River: The final community card is dealt, and the last round of betting takes place.
  5. Showdown: Players reveal their hands to determine the winner. The player with the best five-card poker hand wins the pot.

Key Strategies in Texas Hold’em

Position Matters

  • Early Position: Players in early positions (first to act) have less information and should play tighter.
  • Late Position: Players in late positions (last to act) have more information and can play more hands.

Hand Selection

  • Starting Hands: Choose your starting hands carefully. Premium hands like pairs of Aces, Kings, and Queens, or suited connectors, are generally strong.
  • Adaptability: Adjust your hand selection based on your position and the opponents’ tendencies.

Reading Opponents

  • Tells: Pay attention to physical and verbal tells that can indicate the strength of an opponent’s hand.
  • Betting Patterns: Analyze how opponents bet in different situations to infer their hand strength.

Pot Odds and Implied Odds

  • Pot Odds: Calculate the ratio of the current pot size to the cost of a contemplated call.
  • Implied Odds: Consider future betting rounds to determine if a call is profitable in the long run.

The Cultural Impact of Texas Hold’em

Television and Media

  • World Series of Poker (WSOP): The annual WSOP, featuring the Main Event, has brought Texas Hold’em to millions of viewers worldwide.
  • Poker Shows: Programs like “Poker After Dark” and “High Stakes Poker” have further popularized the game.

Online Poker

  • Poker Platforms: Websites like PokerStars, 888poker, and partypoker offer Texas Hold’em games, allowing players to compete globally.
  • Mobile Apps: Mobile poker apps provide convenience and accessibility, making it easier for players to enjoy the game anytime, anywhere.

Social and Psychological Aspects

  • Community: Texas Hold’em fosters a sense of community among players, with local clubs and tournaments bringing people together.
  • Cognitive Skills: The game sharpens critical thinking, decision-making, and emotional control skills.

Texas Hold’em is more than just a card game; it’s a cultural phenomenon that continues to captivate and challenge players of all skill levels. By mastering the rules, refining your strategies, and understanding the broader context of the game, you can elevate your Texas Hold’em experience and potentially find yourself at the final table of a major tournament. Whether you’re playing for fun or aiming for the big leagues, Texas Hold’em offers endless excitement and opportunities for growth.

poker betting chart

Poker is a game of skill, strategy, and psychology. One of the critical aspects of mastering poker is understanding how to bet effectively. A poker betting chart can be an invaluable tool for both beginners and experienced players. This guide will walk you through the essentials of a poker betting chart, how to use it, and why it’s crucial for improving your game.

What is a Poker Betting Chart?

A poker betting chart is a visual representation of the optimal betting strategies for various stages of a poker game. It helps players make informed decisions based on their hand strength, position at the table, and the actions of their opponents. The chart typically includes information on:

  • Pre-Flop Betting: Decisions before the flop is dealt.
  • Flop Betting: Decisions after the flop is revealed.
  • Turn Betting: Decisions after the turn card is dealt.
  • River Betting: Decisions after the river card is dealt.

Why Use a Poker Betting Chart?

Using a poker betting chart offers several benefits:

  • Consistency: Ensures consistent betting behavior, reducing the likelihood of costly mistakes.
  • Learning Tool: Helps beginners understand optimal betting strategies.
  • Memory Aid: Serves as a quick reference for experienced players.
  • Adaptability: Can be adjusted based on the specific rules and dynamics of the game being played.

Components of a Poker Betting Chart

A typical poker betting chart includes the following components:

1. Hand Rankings

  • Strong Hands: High pairs (e.g., AA, KK) and strong suited connectors (e.g., AKs).
  • Medium Hands: Middle pairs (e.g., 88, 99) and suited cards (e.g., KQs).
  • Weak Hands: Low pairs (e.g., 22, 33) and unsuited cards (e.g., J9o).

2. Position at the Table

  • Early Position: First few seats after the big blind.
  • Middle Position: Seats in the middle of the table.
  • Late Position: Last few seats before the blinds.
  • Button/Dealer Position: The last player to act.

3. Betting Actions

  • Raise: Increase the bet to force others to match or fold.
  • Call: Match the current bet.
  • Check: Pass the action to the next player without betting.
  • Fold: Give up the hand and lose the current bet.

How to Use a Poker Betting Chart

Using a poker betting chart involves the following steps:

  1. Identify Your Hand: Determine the strength of your starting hand.
  2. Determine Your Position: Note your position at the table.
  3. Refer to the Chart: Look up the recommended action based on your hand and position.
  4. Adjust for Opponents: Consider the actions and tendencies of your opponents.

Example of a Simple Poker Betting Chart

Hand Early Position Middle Position Late Position Button/Dealer
AA, KK Raise Raise Raise Raise
QQ, JJ Raise Raise Raise Raise
AKs, AQs Raise Raise Raise Raise
1010, 99 Fold Raise Raise Raise
AJo, KQo Fold Call Raise Raise
77, 66 Fold Fold Call Raise
54s, 43s Fold Fold Call Raise

Customizing Your Poker Betting Chart

While standard charts provide a good starting point, you may need to customize your chart based on:

  • Game Type: Cash games, tournaments, or sit-and-go.
  • Table Dynamics: Aggressive or passive opponents.
  • Stack Sizes: Short-stacked or deep-stacked scenarios.

A poker betting chart is a powerful tool that can significantly enhance your poker game. By understanding and utilizing a betting chart, you can make more informed decisions, reduce mistakes, and improve your overall performance. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced player, incorporating a poker betting chart into your strategy can lead to better results and more enjoyable gameplay.

poker holdem casino

Introduction to Poker Hold’em

Poker Hold’em, often simply referred to as Hold’em, is one of the most popular variants of poker played in casinos worldwide. It is a game of strategy, psychology, and skill, making it a favorite among both casual players and seasoned professionals. Hold’em is played with a standard deck of 52 cards and typically involves anywhere from two to ten players.

The Basics of Poker Hold’em

Game Structure

  1. Pre-Flop: Each player is dealt two hole cards face down. Players then decide whether to bet, call, raise, or fold based on their initial hand.
  2. Flop: Three community cards are dealt face up in the center of the table. Another round of betting ensues.
  3. Turn: A fourth community card is dealt, followed by another round of betting.
  4. River: The final community card is dealt, and the last round of betting takes place.
  5. Showdown: Players reveal their hands, and the best five-card poker hand wins the pot.

Hand Rankings

Understanding the hand rankings is crucial in Hold’em:

  • Royal Flush: A, K, Q, J, 10, all of the same suit.
  • Straight Flush: Five consecutive cards of the same suit.
  • Four of a Kind: Four cards of the same rank.
  • Full House: Three cards of one rank and two cards of another rank.
  • Flush: Five cards of the same suit.
  • Straight: Five consecutive cards of different suits.
  • Three of a Kind: Three cards of the same rank.
  • Two Pair: Two cards of one rank and two cards of another rank.
  • One Pair: Two cards of the same rank.
  • High Card: The highest card in the hand.

Strategies in Poker Hold’em

Position Matters

  • Early Position: The first few players to act. These positions are disadvantageous as they must act first without much information.
  • Middle Position: Players who act after the early positions but before the late positions.
  • Late Position: The last few players to act. These positions are advantageous as they can gather more information before making decisions.

Reading Opponents

  • Tells: Physical or verbal cues that indicate the strength of an opponent’s hand.
  • Betting Patterns: Observing how opponents bet can provide insights into their hand strength.
  • Bluffing: A strategic move to deceive opponents into thinking you have a stronger hand than you do.

Bankroll Management

  • Set Limits: Determine how much you are willing to lose and stick to it.
  • Avoid Tilt: Stay calm and composed, even after a bad beat.
  • Variance: Understand that poker is a game of variance, and short-term losses are part of the game.

Poker Hold’em in Casinos

Live vs. Online Play

  • Live Casinos: Offers a social experience with the thrill of real-time interaction.
  • Online Casinos: Provides convenience and a wider range of games and stakes.
  • Bellagio, Las Vegas: Known for its high-stakes games and professional atmosphere.
  • PokerStars: The largest online poker site, offering a variety of Hold’em games and tournaments.
  • Crown Casino, Melbourne: One of the largest casinos in the world, featuring extensive poker rooms.

Tournaments

  • World Series of Poker (WSOP): The most prestigious poker tournament series, featuring various Hold’em events.
  • World Poker Tour (WPT): Another major tournament series with significant prize pools.
  • Online Tournaments: Regularly hosted by online poker sites, offering opportunities to win big without leaving home.

Poker Hold’em is a captivating game that combines elements of skill, strategy, and psychology. Whether played in a bustling casino or online from the comfort of your home, Hold’em continues to captivate players with its endless possibilities and thrilling gameplay.

Source

  1. poker legal in india
  2. poker legal in india
  3. poker legal in india
  4. poker legal in india
  5. poker legal in india
  6. poker legal in india

Frequently Questions

What are the legal aspects of playing 888 poker in India as discussed on Quora?

Playing 888 poker in India involves understanding the legal landscape, which is complex due to varying state regulations. While the Public Gambling Act of 1867 generally prohibits gambling, it does not explicitly mention online poker. Some states like Nagaland and Sikkim have legalized online gaming with specific licenses. 888 poker operates under international laws, and its legality in India depends on individual state laws. Players should ensure they comply with local regulations and consider the potential risks. Consulting legal experts or referring to Quora discussions can provide further insights into the specific legal aspects of playing 888 poker in India.

Is it legal to play online poker for real money in India?

Playing online poker for real money in India is legal, but the regulations vary by state. In states like Goa and Sikkim, online poker is explicitly permitted and regulated. However, in other states, the legality is less clear, and it's advisable to check local laws. The Public Gambling Act of 1867, which governs gambling laws in India, does not specifically address online poker, leading to differing interpretations. Despite this, many Indians play online poker without legal repercussions. It's crucial to use reputable, licensed platforms to ensure a safe gaming experience and to stay informed about any changes in local regulations.

 

What Are the Legalities of Playing 888 Poker in India?

Playing 888 Poker in India is generally legal, provided you adhere to local regulations. The Public Gambling Act of 1867 is the primary legislation governing gambling in India, but it does not explicitly mention online poker. Instead, the legality is determined by state laws. For instance, states like Goa, Sikkim, and Daman allow casino gaming and poker, including online platforms. 888 Poker operates legally in India by partnering with local operators. However, it's crucial to verify the specific regulations in your state and ensure that 888 Poker complies with local laws to avoid any legal complications.

Are there any legal online poker games in India?

Yes, there are legal online poker games in India, but the legality varies by state. In states like Goa, Daman, and Sikkim, online poker is explicitly legal and regulated. These states have licensed platforms where players can enjoy poker games. However, in other states, the legal status is less clear, and it's advisable to check local laws before participating in online poker. It's crucial to use licensed and regulated platforms to ensure a safe and fair gaming experience. Always verify the platform's credentials and follow local regulations to stay within the bounds of the law.

Are there any legal online poker games in India?

Yes, there are legal online poker games in India, but the legality varies by state. In states like Goa, Daman, and Sikkim, online poker is explicitly legal and regulated. These states have licensed platforms where players can enjoy poker games. However, in other states, the legal status is less clear, and it's advisable to check local laws before participating in online poker. It's crucial to use licensed and regulated platforms to ensure a safe and fair gaming experience. Always verify the platform's credentials and follow local regulations to stay within the bounds of the law.